FacebookTwitter

HAI

Unless otherwise indicated, the material below has not been prepared by Van Eck Associates Corporation or HardAssetsInvestor.com.
Neither assumes any liability for any content on a third party website or material prepared by a third party.

Features and Interviews

   |
Poor Nothing special Worth watching Pretty cool Awesome! 3 Ratings
Rate this article
Thorium: Next-Gen Nuclear Fuel
Written by James Kitler, CFA   
February 09, 2010 2:30 pm EST

 

In his most recent budget, President Obama called for increased support for nuclear energy, and why not? Nuclear power offers a golden combination: the ability to come online in large enough chunks to keep up with demand, with minimal environmental impact. It's no wonder, then, that new players are coming into the market every day, bringing with them new ideas for reactor designs, manufacturing processes—even nuclear fuel.

That's because uranium, plagued by continual supply shortages and storage concerns, is quickly becoming too much of a headache for power and technology companies to navigate. Instead, next-gen nuclear has its eye on a new fuel source: thorium.

 

Thorium: The Other Radioactive Metal

Thorium is a silvery-white, radioactive metal whose stability and brilliance at high temperatures make it ideal for use in heat-resistant ceramics, welding electrodes and even light bulb filaments. The metal is found in trace amounts almost everywhere; with an abundance in the Earth's crust of about 12 parts per million, thorium is several times more prevalent in the soil than its more popular cousin, uranium.

According to the United States Geological Survey, thorium deposits exist in Australia, Brazil, Canada, Greenland (Denmark), India, South Africa and the United States. In the U.S., two private companies hold major thorium claims: privately held Thorium Energy, which holds the claim to the Lemhi Pass in Idaho and Montana; and Wings Iron Ore, which holds Pea Ridge in Missouri, a mine whose ores and tailings are rich in thorium and other rare earth metals.

As recently as 2007, total thorium usage for the U.S. was a mere 3.5 metric tons, according to the USGS; consumption in 2008 and 2009 was so low, the numbers are actually negative. If thorium-based nuclear power takes off, though, it'll be a different story: a single gigawatt (GW) reactor is estimated to use a ton of thorium per year.

Thorium is mostly found in monazite, a byproduct of titanium and zirconium processing which is itself mined for its rare earth elements (REE). But since thorium isn't in great demand right now, the metal is often tossed out with the mine tailings. Indeed, it appears a major source of the thorium the U.S. has imported over the years was the older stocks left over from the processing of rare earth elements by Rhodia Electronics and Catalysis, Inc. in France.

This belies the fact that the fate of thorium supply is deeply tied to the greater rare earth element supply chain—one that has become increasingly dominated by the Chinese. China now produces 97 percent of the world's REE, and according to some analysts, the country may soon require all of it for domestic use. Some Western sources are available, such as Canadian E&P junior Avalon Rare Metals (TSX: AVL) and explorer Quest Uranium (TSX: QUC), but as we've covered before, the supply of REE could likely become a major point of contention in years to come.



 

More on this topic (What's this?)
Nuclear Safety First
Nuclear Power | Uranium Stocks Set To Soar
The Beginning of a Nuclear Revival
Read more on Nuclear Energy, Uranium at Wikinvest
 
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter 

Comments (4)

 Tuesday, 09 February 2010 16:11 EST - Posted by John Faux

 
New reactor design using liquid thorium called Liquid Thorium Flouride Reactor (first investigated 30 years ago) shows great potential for safety and efficiency.

 Wednesday, 10 February 2010 16:29 EST - Posted by Loquacite

 
This article was well-researched and is certainly one of the most accurate ones I've seen in the thorium space. Well done, Mr. Kitler.

There is one point that I would correct you on, however.

Although it is true that significantly less thorium matter is required to generate the same power as a uranium fuel, a 1GW reactor would require more than 1 ton of thorium.

By my calculations, about 22 tonnes would generate the same power as the 240 tonnes of U3O8 normally used in the production of approximately 1 year's worth of fuel for a 1GW reactor.

But reactors won't feed less fuel matter. They will feed the same fuel matter, except thorium, and extract 20 to 40 times as much energy.

Your figures likely refer to the LFTR, which is a red herring for thorium, and may be commercial by 2050. Thorium fuel however will be commercial by 2020, and its development will cost literally 1/10,000th the capex.

 Saturday, 20 March 2010 11:53 EST - Posted by Harijanto Soepangkat

 
The Canadian CANDU nuclear reactor is extremely well suited for the Thorium cycle which has been researched by the Atomic Energy of Canada (AECL) for a few decades.
AECL is probably the only company that is ready for this Thorium cycle.

 Saturday, 20 March 2010 13:48 EST - Posted by Loquacite

 
"AECL is probably the only company that is ready for this Thorium cycle."

There is truth to this statement, but it must be qualified.

AECL is in a partnership with CNNC to burn a 20%-U235-enriched thorium MOX in a CANDU in China. In typical fashion, they are giving away the technology. On the upside, it is not remotely AECL's best technology.

AECL is and will be at the forefront of advanced thorium fuels development and testing, but Canada will not likely agree to burn these fuels in Canadian CANDUs. Indeed, besides the Chinese application, all the work AECL is doing in the thorium fuel realm is for HWR applications.



Post a Comment

Comment
(Limit 2,000
characters) 
*
Name: *
E-mail: *
Home page:

(optional)

Type in the displayed characters
Email follow-up comments to my e-mail address
 


Terms of Use
The HardAssetsInvestor.com message board and comment features are designed to facilitate thoughtful discussion of the biggest issues impacting commodity investors. All comments should be respectful. Insults and profanity are not permitted. The editor reserves the right to remove comments at his/her discretion.

 

Related Articles »

Did you like this article? Then you may be interested in:

  • Defining ‘Criticality’: Mostly Metals
    What does it mean for a mineral to be classified as ‘critical’? And what is the U.S.
    July 19, 2010
  • Niobium. Or Columbium?
    In our latest installment of our Strategic Metals series, we look at niobium, a steel-making metal that could have the potential for so much more.
    June 21, 2010
  • Magnesium: Behind The Bright Shining Light
    In our latest installment of our Minor Metals series, we look at magnesium, a metal with huge reserves—and maybe even bigger potential in the energy industry. 
    May 11, 2010
  • Titanium: The Metal Of The Gods
    In our latest installment of our Strategic Metals series, we look at titanium metal, the exceptional metal key to the aerospace industry.
    March 22, 2010
  • Selenium: Contrary Stuff
    In our latest installment of our Minor Metals series, we take a look at selenium, a contrary metal used in glass, metallurgy and hair care.
    February 22, 2010
 

Commodities Data

July 31, 2010 09:33 PM EST

  Loading data ...
 

Weekly Commodities Poll

Is now a good time to buy gold?

 

Related Articles »

Did you like this article? Then you may be interested in:

  • Defining ‘Criticality’: Mostly Metals
    What does it mean for a mineral to be classified as ‘critical’? And what is the U.S.
    July 19, 2010
  • Niobium. Or Columbium?
    In our latest installment of our Strategic Metals series, we look at niobium, a steel-making metal that could have the potential for so much more.
    June 21, 2010
  • Magnesium: Behind The Bright Shining Light
    In our latest installment of our Minor Metals series, we look at magnesium, a metal with huge reserves—and maybe even bigger potential in the energy industry. 
    May 11, 2010
  • Titanium: The Metal Of The Gods
    In our latest installment of our Strategic Metals series, we look at titanium metal, the exceptional metal key to the aerospace industry.
    March 22, 2010
  • Selenium: Contrary Stuff
    In our latest installment of our Minor Metals series, we take a look at selenium, a contrary metal used in glass, metallurgy and hair care.
    February 22, 2010
 

Seminal Papers »